I wasn't sure what to think when I read your message
I wasn't sure what to think when I walked through the door.
I want you to know I spent a long time on the outfit,
and the hair and the shoes and the makeup
to try and fake up
some kind of courage.
You’re already sitting at the table.
As I approach, you look me in the eye.
I can feel my gaze slipping,
I can see my hand trembling
when I pull my chair aside and say hi.
You say,
“I guess it’s nice to finally put a face to the heartache.”
This is where reality breaks down
And I gotta face the fall out
Misery’s on the menu tonight.
I take my seat and brace myself for the questions.
You shake your head and stare me down,
and I look away.
You ask,
“Did you ever think of me?”
I finally look back and say,
“Every single day”.
This is where reality breaks down
And I gotta face the fall out
Misery’s on the menu tonight.
When you look into the face of a stranger whose heart you broke
it’s hard to know the words to say
cuz there’s no words to say
that would make it okay
and I don’t know how to handle that,
so I, I just look down at my lap
as you, you stare right back.
Now the candles burned low,
food is cold, empty drinks,
waved the waiter away, and I’m spilling the secrets.
Answering every question, there’s no more lies,
and with every detail, the pain in your eyes
only grows, and I know, I could quit while ahead
but it almost feels nice to hear the truth being said.
And when the story is over, it’s finally done,
we both sit in silence, cuz we got what we came for.
Misery’s on the menu tonight.
And as we stand to leave, you say
“I hope you never forget my face.”